18 Sep
Humour me, and let’s just think for a moment about using a male critic’s guidelines in order to bury female-created content under a mountain of off-hand snark masquerading as genuine cineaste dialogue.

And if there was a kernel of feminist thought in the initial MPDG discussion (i.e. the notion that male writer/directors were creating unrealistic characters), the point-blank dismissal of any eccentric female characters as MPDGs has dissolved into something closer to, at worst, sexism, and at best, incredibly lazy cultural commentary.

Here’s an example: before Valerie Faris and Jonathon Dayton’s Ruby Sparks had even been released - i.e. based on the trailer alone - blogs were ablaze with the notion that it was the “ultimate Manic Pixie Dream Girl” film and, thus, worthy of little more than derision (and certainly not ticket sales).

(I am reminded of writer and former Man Booker Prize judge Rick Gekoski’s observation that, in the era of the blogosphere, “the notion that some opinions are better than others - fairer, deeper and more cogent - seems to be slipping from our grasp”.)

In the lazy obsession with qualifying films by their apparent tropes, the hair-trigger dismissal of MPDGs has, I think, directly contributed to the slating of films written and directed by women. And the non-stop slating of films written and directed by women directly leads to Hollywood producers saying, “You know what? That one film written/directed by a woman this year didn’t go so well, so we’re going to pass.”

(If you think the sudden glut of “raunchy” comedies with female leads isn’t linked to studios’ having waited to see how Bridesmaids went, I also have some flying pigs you may be interested in purchasing.)


I’ve had it with your shitty need to dismiss female characters and the female filmmakers who write/direct them. 

The problem with Manic Pixie dream girls

(via clambistro)

  1. demi-femme reblogged this from feministfilm
  2. spookyyy-mulder reblogged this from superfemme-inist
  3. potluck-on-the-left reblogged this from feministfilm
  4. innereyebrow reblogged this from into-the-weeds
  5. thebestisunkind reblogged this from into-the-weeds
  6. merdeandmore reblogged this from into-the-weeds
  7. into-the-weeds reblogged this from fourloves
  8. dregsofmegs reblogged this from gaynxiety
  9. ignatius-m reblogged this from gaynxiety
  10. stopcallingmewitch reblogged this from feministfilm
  11. strangersatthemall reblogged this from samasever
  12. femme-unculus reblogged this from gaynxiety
  13. sconesandteaforall reblogged this from feministfilm
  14. roses-in-flux reblogged this from feministfilm
  15. wildbayou reblogged this from clambistro
  16. gaynxiety reblogged this from pancake-sexual
  17. pancake-sexual reblogged this from feministfilm
  18. partiallythere reblogged this from feministfilm
  19. samasever reblogged this from obstinatecondolement
  20. obstinatecondolement reblogged this from feministfilm
  21. cornwankies reblogged this from clambistro